Stuck With Your Novel? Start Here.
Every writer reaches a point where something in a story isn’t working.
Sometimes the problem is obvious. Often it isn’t. You know the story has slowed down, a character feels wrong, the dialogue isn’t convincing or the plot has stopped moving, but understanding why can be much harder.
These are the grey areas of writing a novel: the moments when you know something needs fixing but can’t quite identify what has gone wrong.
The Writer’s Black Book is designed to help you identify those problems, understand what is causing them and find practical ways forward.
Start with the problem that sounds most like yours.
I Have an Idea, But I Don't Know What the Story Is
Having an interesting idea isn’t the same as having a story.
You may have a character, setting, situation or intriguing what if? but when you try to develop it into a novel, nothing seems to happen.
The missing ingredient is often change and conflict.
Ask yourself: What happens that prevents my protagonist’s life from continuing as it did before?
Then ask what your protagonist wants as a result, what stands in the way and what happens if they fail.
You don’t need to know the entire plot yet. You need enough conflict and consequence to make something happen next.
Look at: Premise · Conflict · Character Goals · Stakes · Story Direction
I Know the Beginning and Ending, But I Can't Build the Middle
You know how the story starts. You may even know how it ends.
The problem is everything between them.
A difficult middle often indicates that the story isn’t generating enough consequences. Events occur, but they don’t sufficiently change the situation or make the protagonist’s objective harder to achieve.
Ask yourself: What becomes more difficult because of what just happened?
The middle of a novel shouldn’t merely occupy the distance between setup and resolution. It should progressively remove easy solutions, increase consequences and force more difficult choices.
Look at: Premise · Conflict · Character Goals · Stakes · Story Direction
My Protagonist Isn't Driving the Story
Your protagonist is present in every important scene, yet somehow the story seems to happen to them.
This usually occurs when the character spends too much time reacting to decisions made by other people or responding to events they did not influence.
Ask yourself: What decision does my protagonist make that changes what happens next?
Characters become active when their goals lead to choices and those choices produce consequences.
They can make mistakes. They can choose badly. In fact, poor decisions often create excellent fiction.
What matters is that their presence changes the direction of the story.
Look at: Premise · Conflict · Character Goals · Stakes · Story Direction
My Scenes Feel Disconnected
Individual scenes may work perfectly well, yet the novel still feels like a collection of separate episodes.
The problem is often causality.
Ask yourself: Why does this scene happen because of what happened before it?
Then ask: What does this scene cause to happen next?
Not every connection needs to be obvious, but important scenes should rarely exist in isolation.
A decision creates a consequence. A discovery changes an objective. A mistake creates a complication. A confrontation damages a relationship.
The story begins to flow when scenes create reasons for subsequent scenes to exist.
Look at: Premise · Conflict · Character Goals · Stakes · Story Direction
My Dialogue Works, But Everybody Sounds the Same
The dialogue may be grammatically correct and perfectly understandable, yet every character seems to speak with the same voice.
The problem may not be vocabulary or accents.
Characters sound different because they want different things, notice different things and communicate in different ways.
Ask yourself: What does this character want from this conversation?
One person may avoid confrontation. Another may provoke it. One explains everything. Another reveals almost nothing. One uses humour when uncomfortable. Another becomes formal.
Character voice grows from personality, experience, intention and circumstance.
Look at: Premise · Conflict · Character Goals · Stakes · Story Direction
Something Is Wrong With the Pacing, But I Can't Identify It
Pacing problems are frustrating because the manuscript can feel too slow in one place and too fast somewhere else.
The instinctive solution is often to shorten scenes or add action.
That may not solve the real problem.
Ask yourself: Is the amount of time I’m giving this moment proportional to its importance?
Important developments sometimes need space. Routine transitions usually don’t. A revelation may need time for its consequences to register, while information the reader already understands may need considerably less.
Pacing isn’t simply about writing faster.
It is about controlling where the reader’s attention and time are spent.
Look at: Premise · Conflict · Character Goals · Stakes · Story Direction
My Story Should Be Tense, But It Isn't
You have danger, conflict or high stakes on the page, but the reader still doesn’t feel much tension.
Danger alone isn’t enough.
Tension develops when the reader understands that something matters, recognises what might go wrong and has to wait to discover the outcome.
Ask yourself: What is the reader waiting to happen, and why should they care?
Sometimes the solution is not adding another threat. It is making the existing threat clearer, more personal or more uncertain.
Look at: Premise · Conflict · Character Goals · Stakes · Story Direction
I've Reached a Dead End and Don't Know What Happens Next
This happens to planners and discovery writers alike.
The story has reached a point where every possible direction seems forced, predictable or simply wrong.
Rather than asking: What should happen next?
try asking: What would my characters do next because of what has just happened?
Return to their objectives, fears, relationships and unresolved problems.
A decision may have consequences that haven’t yet been explored. A previous solution may have created another problem. Someone may possess information that changes the situation.
Often the way forward is already contained in what you’ve written.
Look at: Premise · Conflict · Character Goals · Stakes · Story Direction
I've Finished My First Draft, But I Don't Know Whether the Story Works
Finishing a first draft is a major achievement, but it creates a completely different problem.
You are no longer asking what happens next.
You are asking whether everything that happened belongs together.
Don’t begin by correcting sentences.
First examine the story itself.
Ask: What is this novel fundamentally about, and does the finished manuscript deliver the story I intended to tell?
Look at the protagonist’s objective, central conflict, major turning points, character development, escalation and ending.
Structural problems should be addressed before polishing prose. There is little value in perfecting a scene that may eventually need to disappear.
Look at: Premise · Conflict · Character Goals · Stakes · Story Direction
A Quick Story Diagnostic
Before making major changes to your manuscript, try answering these six questions:
1. What does my protagonist want?
2. What prevents them from getting it?
3. What happens because they try?
4. How does their situation become progressively more difficult?
5. What does the reader want to discover?
6. What final choice or consequence resolves the central conflict?
If one of those questions is particularly difficult to answer, don’t regard that as failure.
You may just have found the part of the story that needs your attention.
You Don't Have to Solve Everything at Once
Writing a novel means solving hundreds of interconnected problems.
Changing a character’s motivation may strengthen the plot. Fixing the plot may improve the pacing. Improving scene objectives may make the dialogue more convincing. Strengthening consequences may create the tension that was previously missing.
The important thing is to identify what isn’t working before trying to fix it.
The Writer’s Black Book will continue to explore these grey areas through practical books, articles, diagnostic guides, worksheets and writing tools.
When you encounter the next problem, come back and start with the question:
What’s not working, and why?
The Black Book in Your Inbox
Practical ideas about storytelling, fiction writing and the craft behind compelling stories – delivered directly to your inbox.
Discover new articles, writing techniques, useful resources and occasional updates from The Writer’s Black Book.
No noise. No generic writing advice. Just useful ideas you can put to work.
Enter your email address to receive The Writer’s Black Book writing resources, articles, book news and updates. You can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy for details.
No spam. Just practical writing advice from The Writer’s Black Book. Unsubscribe anytime.